Blackwater Siren
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Blackwater Siren Menu

Menu Blackwater Siren-1
Menu Blackwater Siren-1
Menu Blackwater Siren-2
Menu Blackwater Siren-2
Menu Blackwater Siren-3
Menu Blackwater Siren-3
Menu Blackwater Siren-4
Menu Blackwater Siren-4
Menu Blackwater Siren-5
Menu Blackwater Siren-5
Menu Blackwater Siren-6
Menu Blackwater Siren-6
Menu Blackwater Siren-7
Menu Blackwater Siren-7
Menu Blackwater Siren-8
Menu Blackwater Siren-8

Bottle Beer

Bud Light
$3.25
Budweiser
$3.25
Miller Lite
$3.25
Coors Light
$3.25
Michelob Ultra
$3.25
Michelob Amberbock
$3.25
Corona Extra
$4.50
Corona Light
$4.50
Heineken
$4.50
Guinness
$4.50
Strongbow Apple Cider
$4.50
Beck's Non Alcoholic
$4.50

Draft Beer

Miller Lite
$3.50
Stella Artois
$5.00
Lagunitas Ipa
$5.00
India pale ale
Florida Keys Brewering Co
$5.50
Islamorada Ale
$5.50
Island citrus ale

Specialty Drinks

Mermaid Water
$9.00
Parrot bay key lime rum, blue curacao, banana liqueur, pineapple juice
Blackwater Bucket
$15.00
shots of flavored bacardi - mango, pineapple, coconut, & tangerine served with homemade punch in a bucket
Drunken Sailor
$7.00
Double shot of sailor jerry spiced rum & coke
Key Largo Lemonade
$8.00
Parrot bay key lime rum, pineapple, lemonade
Walk The Plank
$8.50
Bacardi mango, pineapple, chamborg raspberry liquor
House Margarita
$8.00
Golden Margarita
$11.50
Cuervo gold & grand marnier
The Siren
$13.50
Patron silver or el cazadores reposado tequila, grand marnier, fresh lime, sour, & agave nector
Spicy Margarita
$13.50
Patron or el cazadores tequila, grand marnier, sour, muddled limes & fresh jalapenos
Traditional Mojito
$9.00
Bacardi, muddled lime & mint
Flavored Mojito
$10.00
Coconut or strawberry
Dirty Martini
$12.50
Grey goose or kettle one
Key Lime Martini
Titos, key lime liqueur, fresh lime..cosmo...Vodka, cointreau, fresh lime, cranberry
Pina Colada
$9.00
Strawberry Margarita
$9.00
Strawberry Daquiri
$9.00
Margarita
$9.00
Rum Runner
$9.00
Mud Slide
$9.00

Appetizers

Smoked Fish Dip
$10.99
A blend of smoked fish, cream cheese, & spices served with crackers & fresh veggies
Jalapeno Poppers
$7.99
Homemade jalapenos stuffed with cheddar, cream cheese, & crab fried in crispy panko
Conch Fritters
$7.99
Mildly spicy mixture of conch & seasoned stuffing deep fried to a crisp
Calamari
$9.99
Lightly fried calamari served with savory marinara sauce
Chips & Pico
$6.99
Freshly fried tortilla chips served with homemade chunky pico de gallo
Peel & Eat Shrimp
$8.99
Half pound of shrimp cooked in old bay seasoning & served cold with cocktail sauce
Seasoned Waffle Fries
$4.99
Sweet Potato Fries
$6.99
Small Garden Salad
$4.49
Caesar Salad
$4.49
Small Garden Salad Plus
$5.49
Shredded cheese, bacon bits, croutons
Mozzarella Sticks
$6.99
Mozzarella breaded & fried
Sampler
$13.99
Seared tuna, fritters, jalapeno poppers, & mozzarella sticksseared tuna, fritters, jalapeno poppers, & mozzarella sticks
Coconut Onion Rings
$7.99
Large cut onions in coconut breading served with sweet chili sauce
Onion Rings
$6.99
Homemade large cut beer batter onion rings
Coconut Shrimp
$10.99
Large butterflied shrimp in coconut breading
Firecracker Shrimp
$10.99
Large butterflied shrimp in jalapeno breading served with creamy sweet chili sauce
Seared Tuna
$13.99
Sashimi grade yellowfin tuna seared, thinly sliced, & served with ginger, wasabi, soy sauce & seaweed salad
Quesadilla
$5.99
Your choice of filling & cheese in a flour tortilla served with sour cream, salsa, & pico de gallo choose grilled or blackened
Chicken Wings
$9.99
A mix of wings and drummies tossed in the sauce of your choosing, served with blue cheese and celery. Mild buffalo, hot buffalo, bbq, blackened, thai bbq, teriyaki, hot teriyaki, hot garlic, habenero
New England Clam Chowder
$4.99
Creamy white clam chowder
Loaded Chili
$4.99
Chili topped with shredded cheese & onions
Spicy Shrimp Gazpacho
$4.99
Cold tomato based soup with shrimp, cilantro, cucumber, & a hint of jalapeno

Salads

Garden Salad
$6.49
Mixed salad greens, tomato, cucumber, & red onion
Garden Salad Plus
$7.99
Garden salad with shredded cheese, bacon bits, & croutons
Caesar Salad
$6.49
Crisp romaine tossed in creamy caesar dressing, topped with shredded parmesan & seasoned croutons
Buffalo Chicken Salad
$11.99
Fried chicken tenders tossed in hot buffalo sauce atop a garden or caesar salad topped with blue cheese crumbs
Salad Sampler
$13.49
A scoop of each homemade tuna salad, crab salad, pasta salad, potato salad & coleslaw atop a garden or caesar salad
Shrimp & Spinach Salad
$14.99
Blackened shrimp atop a salad of spinach, tomato, cucumbers, red onion, bacon bits, & crumbled feta cheese

Wrap It Up

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$10.99
Fried chicken tenders tossed in hot buffalo sauce wrapped in a fresh flour tortilla with lettuce, tomato, & blue cheese.
Blackened Spinach Wrap
$11.49
Your choice of meat, spinach, feta, tomato, red onion, bacon, & lite balsamic vinaigrette
Taco Wrap
$10.99
Your choice of meat blackened, lettuce, shredded cheese, fresh pico de gallo, & baja sauce
Caesar Wrap
$10.99
Romaine lettuce, shredded parmesan, chopped tomato, & delicious caesar dressing choose grilled or blackened
Ahi Tuna & Seaweed Wrap
$14.99
Blackened and seared sushi grade ahi tuna, seaweed salad, lettuce, tomato, & wasabi aioli served with a teriyaki glaze sauce

New Beers

Modelo
Corona Premier
Miller High Life

White Claw / Mango + Blk,Cherry

Prime Rib Dinner
Lobster Tail
Chicken Enchiladas

Fish

Hog
Mahi Mahi
Grouper
Whole Fried Yellowtail

Sandwiches

Fresh Catch
Prices on the menu reflect fresh mahi mahi. Ask your server what other fresh fish we have available today! Choose
Harvey Fish Sandwich
$11.99
A key largo traditional favorite. Grilled mahi with american cheese, tomato, & tartar sauce toasted on whole wheat bread. Some like it blackened choose
Macho Fish Sandwich
$12.49
Kick the harvey up a notch with this customer favorite. Blackened mahi with cheddar, tomato, jalapenos, & jalapeno tartar sauce toasted together on whole wheat choose
Tuna Melt
$9.99
The best homemade tuna salad around with swiss cheese meited on toasted whole wheat

Draft Beer Pints

Yuengling
$3.75
Lager
Stella Artois
$5.75
Belgian pilsner .% abv
Key West Sunset Ale
$5.75
Florida beer co. Amber ale % abv
Islamorada Ale
$5.75
Islamorada brewing co citrus ale % abv
Channel Marker
$5.75
Islamorada brewing co. Ipa .% abv
Crazy Lady
$5.75
Waterfront brewery key west honey blonde ale .% abv

Siven Starters

Smoked Fish Dip
$8.99
A blend of smoked fish, cream cheese, & spices served with multigrain crackers & fresh veggies
Jalapeno Poppers
$7.99
Fresh jalapenos stuffed with cheddar, cream cheese, & crab fried in crispy panko
Conch Fritters
$7.99
Mildly spicy mixture of conch & seasoned stuffing deep fried to a crisp
Calamari
$9.99
Lightly fried calamari served with savory marinara sauce
Chips & Pico
$6.99
Freshly fried tortilla chips served with homemade chunky pico de gallo
Peel & Eat Shrimp
$8.99
Half pound of shrimp cooked in old bay seasoning. served cold with cocktail sauce
Mozzarella Sticks
$6.99
Mozzarella breaded & fried
Soups
$4.99
New England Clam Chowder
Creamy white clam chowder key largo cook-off winner!!
Loaded Chili
Chili topped with shredded cheese & onions
Spicy Shrimp Gazpacho
Cold tomato based soup with shrimp, cilantro, cucumber, & a hint of jalapeno
Small Garden
$4.49
Caesar Salad
$4.49
Small Garden Salad Plus
$5.49
Shredded cheese, bacon bits, croutons
App Sampler
$13.99
Seared tuna, conch fritters, jalapeno poppers, & mozzarella sticks
Coconut Onion Rings
$7.99
Large cut onions in coconut breading served with sweet chili sauce
Onion Rings
$6.99
Homemade large cut beer batter onion rings
Fried Shrimp Apps
$10.99
Each
Coconut Shrimp Served With Thai Sauce
$10.99
Each
Firecracker Shrimp In Jalapeno Breading
$10.99
Each
Buffalo Shrimp Panko Breaded & Tossed In Hot Sauce
$10.99
Each
Seared Tuna
$14.99
Sashimi grade yellowfin tuna seared, thinly sliced, & served with ginger, wasabi, soy sauce & seaweed
Quesadilla
$6.99
Your choice of filling & cheese in a flour tortilla served with sour cream, salsa, & pico de gallo meat choice
Chicken Wings
$9.99
A mix of wings and drummies tossed in the sauce of your choosing, served with blue cheese and celery. Mild buffalo, hot buffalo, bbq, blackened, thai bbq, teriyaki, hot teriyaki, hot garlic, habanero
Basket Of Fries
$4.99

Side Choices

Coleslaw
Bowtie Pasta Salad
Potato Salad

Chicken & Pork

Bbq Pulled Pork Sandwich
$8.99
Tender pork smothered in bbq sauce on a fresh kaiser roll
Spicy Southwest Bbq Sandwich
$10.99
Tender pork in habanero bbq topped with provolone cheese & fresh pico de gallo

Burger In Paradise

Black & Blue Burger
$10.99
Blackened hamburger topped with melted blue cheese crumbs & served with the same fresh fixings consumer advisory: consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Mushroom & Swiss Burger
$11.99
Sautéed mushrooms & aged swiss cheese atop the burger with same fresh fixings consumer advisory: consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Hamburger
$9.99
Fresh made / pound ground beef patty seasoned & served with lettuce, tomato, & onion consumer advisory: consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Make Any Burger Bigger
Make Any Burger Better

Others

Build A Philly

When stepping into Blackwater Siren, the menu offers a tantalizing selection of dishes and drinks that promise to elevate your dining experience. Whether you're craving a refreshing beer or something more adventurous, the drink offerings won’t disappoint. Their draft beer list features favorites like Miller Lite, Stella Artois, and Lagunitas IPA, while the Bottle Beer section includes well-known brands such as Bud Light and Michelob Ultra. For those seeking something special, their Specialty Drinks like Mermaid Water, Blackwater Bucket, and Drunken Sailor are sure to satisfy with vibrant, tropical flavors.

The appetizer selection is a perfect start to any meal, with options like Smoked Fish Dip, Jalapeno Poppers, and the ever-popular Conch Fritters. Each dish is packed with flavor and showcases the unique coastal vibe of the restaurant. For something lighter, the Garden Salad or Caesar Salad offers a fresh option, while the Buffalo Chicken Salad brings in a bit of heat for spice lovers.

The wraps here are a standout, offering dishes such as the Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Blackened Spinach Wrap, and Ahi Tuna & Seaweed Wrap—each filled with fresh, high-quality ingredients. For a heartier meal, their Prime Rib Dinner, Lobster Tail, and Chicken Enchiladas are not to be missed. The Fresh Catch Sandwich and Harvey Fish Sandwich showcase the best of local seafood, while the Black & Blue Burger and Mushroom & Swiss Burger offer a delicious twist for burger enthusiasts.

With side choices like Coleslaw, Potato Salad, and a variety of specialty sandwiches, Blackwater Siren’s menu perfectly combines comfort and coastal cuisine, ensuring there's something for everyone.

Blackwater Siren

Blackwater Siren is a Tiki Bar located in Key Largo, FL, offering American and Seafood cuisine. With a divey, casual vibe, it provides many vegetarian options and is wheelchair accessible. Enjoy outdoor seating, happy hour specials, and a full bar. This woman-owned establishment also offers catering and has a pool table. Contact them at (305) 780-7382 for reservations or takeout/delivery options.

Follow Us
  • facebook
  • Yelp
  • tripadvisor
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.